Choosing Between Balayage and Highlights: A Comprehensive Guide

When it comes to transforming your hair with color, the choices can be overwhelming. Among the most popular techniques are balayage and highlights. Both can add dimension, brightness, and a fresh look to your hair, but they each offer distinct results. Understanding the differences between balayage and highlights is essential to making the right choice for your desired look and lifestyle. In this guide, we’ll break down everything you need to know to make an informed decision.

What is Balayage?

Balayage, a term derived from the French word “to sweep,” is a freehand painting technique used to apply color to the hair. Unlike traditional methods that use foils or caps, balayage is applied by hand, resulting in a more natural, sun-kissed look. The color is typically concentrated on the surface of the hair rather than being saturated through the section, allowing for a more blended and graduated effect.

Pros of Balayage

  1. Natural Appearance: Balayage creates a soft, natural look, mimicking the way hair lightens in the sun.
  2. Low Maintenance: As the color is more subtle and blended, regrowth is less noticeable, meaning fewer trips to the salon.
  3. Customizable: The freehand technique allows colorists to tailor the look to suit individual hair types and personal preferences.
  4. Versatile: Suitable for any hair color and length, though particularly striking on long, wavy hair.

Cons of Balayage

  1. Cost: Typically more expensive than traditional highlights due to the skill and time required.
  2. Time-Consuming: The application process can take longer, especially for intricate designs and color placements.
  3. Subtlety: Those looking for a dramatic change may find balayage too understated.

What are Highlights?

Highlights involve sectioning the hair and applying color using foils or a cap. This method results in more uniform and precise streaks of color throughout the hair. Highlights can vary in thickness and placement, from chunky and bold to fine and subtle.

Pros of Highlights

  1. Bold Contrast: Highlights can create a striking contrast, adding depth and dimension to the hair.
  2. Variety: There are numerous highlighting techniques (e.g., babylights, foilyage) that can achieve different looks.
  3. Customizable Intensity: Depending on the placement and thickness, highlights can range from subtle to dramatic.
  4. Quick Results: Highlighting can be a quicker process compared to balayage, depending on the desired look.

Cons of Highlights

  1. Maintenance: Regrowth can be more noticeable, necessitating frequent touch-ups.
  2. Potential Damage: The use of foils and lighteners can be harsher on the hair, leading to potential damage if not done properly.
  3. Less Natural: Highlights often create a more structured and less natural look compared to balayage.

Choosing the Right Technique for You

When deciding between balayage and highlights, consider the following factors:

Hair Type and Length

  • Balayage: Best suited for medium to long hair, particularly wavy or curly textures. The freehand technique allows for a more blended look that complements the natural movement of the hair.
  • Highlights: Suitable for all hair lengths and types. Highlights can be adapted to create various effects, from subtle to bold, making them a versatile option.

Desired Look

  • Balayage: Ideal for those seeking a natural, sun-kissed appearance with soft, seamless transitions. Balayage is perfect if you want a low-maintenance, effortless look.
  • Highlights: Great for individuals who want more defined streaks of color and noticeable contrast. Highlights can create a polished, high-impact style.

Maintenance and Lifestyle

  • Balayage: Requires less frequent touch-ups, making it a practical choice for those with busy lifestyles or those who prefer a lower-maintenance hair routine.
  • Highlights: Typically require more regular maintenance to keep the roots looking fresh. If you enjoy visiting the salon regularly and maintaining a precise look, highlights might be the better option.

Cost and Time

  • Balayage: Generally more expensive due to the skill and time involved. The application process can take longer, but the results are long-lasting, reducing the frequency of salon visits.
  • Highlights: Can be more affordable and quicker to apply, though the need for regular touch-ups can add to the overall cost and time commitment over the long term.

Combining Balayage and Highlights

For those who can’t decide between the two techniques, combining balayage and highlights is also an option. This hybrid approach can offer the best of both worlds: the natural, blended look of balayage with the added dimension and brightness of highlights. This technique, often referred to as “foilyage,” involves applying balayage and then enhancing certain sections with foils for extra contrast and lightness.


Choosing between balayage and highlights ultimately depends on your personal preferences, hair type, lifestyle, and desired look. Balayage offers a natural, low-maintenance option that blends seamlessly with your hair’s natural movement, while highlights provide a bold, defined style with various customization options. By considering the pros and cons of each technique, you can make an informed decision that best suits your needs.

Whether you opt for the sun-kissed subtlety of balayage or the striking contrast of highlights, both techniques have the potential to elevate your look and boost your confidence. Consult with a professional colorist to discuss your goals and find the perfect approach for your hair. With the right choice, you’ll be well on your way to achieving a stunning, head-turning style.

Leave a Comment